¡ LIVE NOW @ live.novaramedia.com !
real economy Syriza Feminism Economy Anarcho-syndicalism Seth Wheeler hydra Eurozone crisis Eleanor Saitta outsourcing strikes Keynesianism Emma Dowling Budget2014 Will Davies media Hannah Forbes Black columnism Communism Greece finance university America welfare Economics projects city Irish Water strike Mark Fisher Novara Wire interviews Heygate Centre Left sex work Paul Mason gfc social impact bonds immigration Autonomia Matthew Beaumont utopia race London UK reform Duggan migration Democrat Party Jacqueline Rose Class Capitalist Realism gentrification future Shiv Malik Europe Full employment left conservatives morgage Spain situationism Intellectual Property LGBT Post-Traumatic Subject surplus colonialism David Harvey Ashok Kumar Dawkins graduate Will Hutton Melissa Gira literature Meek 2015 piercepenniless Eurozone elitism Podemos best of wire work Transfeminism Dawn Foster FBB self-employment Rabina Khan Police China Deleuze defence George Osborne oil ukip LGBTQ Nina Power bbc protest Ethical Capitalism Negri student politics further education trolling social movements debt Tory party Refusal of Work McKenzie Wark youth Post Fordism Psychiatry Compass no borders Immaterial Labour Luther Blissett Laurie Penny regeneration Copyright Luxury neoliberalism co-operatives student housing funds Post-Capitalism riots m5s AskNovara Autonomism funeral Black Politics English Indyref Tower Hamlets edl Neal Lawson housing history Dan Trilling 15M queer conservatism automation low pay Beppe Grillo Andrew McGettigan anti-fascism State-form nationalism Marxism Natalie Bennett Ralph Miliband Globalization trade unions Thatcher blacklivesmatter Syndicalism Privatisation David Graeber long recession Green Party Israel energy Football bnp Danny Hayward crisis Federico Campagna Secular Crisis Corbyn Capitalism Owen Jones technology Shlomo Sand productivity Oxi Anarchism Merkel prison Ed Miliband Plan A Elections Ken Silverstein GE2015 2013 Germany Marx racism White Supremacism FALC liliana Dmitrovic policing growth TUC pride Austerity Saul Newman Richard Seymour Labour mob intellectual England European Elections Social Democracy Mental Health ACAB Scotland IMO financialisation right death revolution ukba workfare Green Climate Change Franco Berardi rent higher education journalism optimism 2020 Labour Party fascism Wu Ming state UKUncut atheism US Italy Kristin Ross Grexit Environment internet

Marx contra Dawkins

“Man is the world of man – state, society. This state and this society produce religion, which is an inverted consciousness of the world, because they are an inverted world. (…) Religious suffering is, at one and the same time, the expression of real suffering and a protest against real suffering. Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. (…) The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness. To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions. (…) Criticism has plucked the imaginary flowers on the chain not in order that man shall continue to bear that chain without fantasy or consolation, but so that he shall throw off the chain and pluck the living flower.” (Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, 1843)

That would be Karl Marx, being smarter about religion than Richard Dawkins will ever be, 170 years ago. The same text include the line about religion as ‘the opium of the masses’, which is probably the most wildly misused line from Marx. Opium was a medicine and comfort while also being a potent drug – when the phrase is used to mean “LOL religious people are so dumb it’s like they’re on smack LOL I am the great rationalist”, it misses precisely Marx’s recognition of the *social function* of religion, as well as its contradictory content, as both protest against suffering and a consolation that often enables its perpetuation. On that consolatory function, this: I was raised Catholic. When my grandfather was in the weeks where he was dying, I found myself in Soho Square – for non-Londoners, the heart of London’s historical gay district – reading in the sun. To the east of the square is a Catholic church, one of first built after Catholics were allowed to build churches in England again. I received a phonecall telling me to come to the hospital this evening, because the time was coming near. I found myself walking into the church and sitting down on one of the back pews. I genuflected, because muscle memory is hard to overcome, even when you haven’t been in a church for many years. I didn’t pray. But I thought about the instinctive Catholicism, deep-rooted, of my grandfather’s generation. I thought of his early jobs, of which he was so proud, hauling flour on the docks at the age of 14 (“earning a man’s wage so young.”) I thought of his war service and its horrors. I thought of his hands, back and knees giving out because he had worked all the flex out of them. I thought of his particular stubbornness. I thought of him lying in a bed a few miles away on a drip, all the weight gone out of him. I thought of him ill-treated by the state, unwilling to provide in his last years a small measure of justice for what he had done for decades. The impossible inequality of that never-agreed contract. I thought we do struggle with the powers of this world, princes and potentates – Ephesians – and I thought about redemption. What would redeem the endless work, the stress, the privation and the loss of over eighty years. How to give thanks, also, that to be born in a tenement in Bermondsey was not always to die there. How to finally understand the attraction of the promise of redemption and the horizon of a new world, in which the manifest injustices – the things left unfinished – shall have passed away. I don’t believe the New Jerusalem is waiting for us. And I could see, walking out of that church, how such a promise might be an inducement to inaction. But I also thought how all the old stories and psalms had a better way of naming and giving shape to the – very normal – suffering of a boy losing his grandfather, the sense of a pain shared and repeated many thousands of times over the generations, and a sharpening rage for the quotidian misery that made up so much of his daily work. I don’t think this is an easy fable. In some way it restates the obvious, about pain and knowledge and reflection. Heart of a heartless world indeed.

Related Posts: